The first bagel store on Shelter Island, we offer artisan bagels made from scratch daily with an array of pairings. These include some that are — you guessed it — eccentric. And enjoy our unique interior vibe created by Ricky Teevee.
Choose from specialty bagels such as Za’atar, rosemary, salt, garlic, parmesan, asiago, chocolate chip, and jalapeno cheddar. Build your own bagel by adding meats, cheeses, salads and toppings.
Try our pizza bagels or our one-of-kind bagel dogs (yep, they’re bagel-wrapped hot dogs and you’ll be hooked). We offer all-day sandwiches and salads, as well as bagels by the dozen and toppings by the pound.
We’d be happy to cater your next event, or work with you on a promotion for a cause.
Hours: Tuesday to Sunday, 7 AM to 3 PM (plus, open on holiday Mondays) for takeout, or dine under a festive umbrella at one of our colorful picnic tables. Call ahead and we’ll have your order ready for pickup.
LOCATION
